Dear Mrs. Jeanetta Calhoun Mish,
My name is Lily, and I am a senior at The Ethel Walker School in Simsbury, Connecticut. In my English class English 12 – Friendship: Tried and True, we were tasked with partaking in the Dear Poet 2020. I listen to and read various poems listed on the site, but when I read yours, I was instantly intrigued and decided this is who I would like to write a letter to.
When I first read your poem, I envisioned Michael standing behind the sill with his palms touching the glass as he watched the hummingbird flutter in the air. But, once I reached the next stanza, I realized the boy trapped inside the window was the hummingbird, not Michael. It’s interesting the way you gave the hummingbird a gender since most people refer to animals with the noun rather than use pronouns (In case this isn’t clear, here’s my elaboration. 1. Look at that turtle over there! Isn’t it huge? Versus 2. I heard there is a coyote out here. We better look out for him.) Is there a particular reason why you did this or am I reading too much into your diction here?
I am quite fond of the lack of capitalization and punctuation in this poem. I was first introduced to this stylistic device in Lucille Clifton’s poetry, and let me tell you, I adore it. It makes the poem feel calm, just like the narrator’s voice as she tells this story for her son. Not only that, but I feel the lack of punctuation makes the few instances of punctuation that much more important; each one has a specific purpose that would otherwise be lost if the whole poem was full of commas, periods, and dashes. This brings me to my question: Does the lack of capitalization and punctuation make you feel free? If it does, is it more liberating than switching from lined paper to printer paper for the first time?
Additionally, I thoroughly enjoyed the simple, yet vivid vocabulary you used in this poem. I could picture from the mother picking up the hummingbird and bringing him outside to the moment he flies off. When I was about 6 years old and still lived in Georgia, my family had seen quite a few hummingbirds get trapped near the roof of our carport, yet, since the car port was open on all four sides, contrastingly to your poem, there was no window preventing the hummingbird from the outside. Both instances, the hummingbird gets the help it needs, and those who helped him watch him fly away.
Something about those last two stanzas resonates deeply within my soul; the clarity and conciseness of the final 10 words leave an imprint on my heart. It reminds me of the saying “If you love something, let it go.” In this case, the mother resists her motherly urge to nurture the dear hummingbird and instead lets it go. It’s such a powerful message to leave the reader since it’s something most people struggle with after a breakup or life-changing event.
This brings me to my final question. Has there been an instance in your life where you let something go that you wish you hadn’t?
As always during this crazy time of COVID-19, stay safe.
Best,
Lily
Grade 12
Simsbury, CT