| Year | Title | Publisher | Prize Amount | Judges |
| 1955 | The Middle Voice | Alan Swallow | $5,000 | Louise Bogan |
| Rolfe Humphries | ||||
| Randall Jarrell | ||||
| May Sarton | ||||
| Mark Van Doren |
| Year | Title | Publisher | Prize Amount | Judges |
| 1955 | The Middle Voice | Alan Swallow | $5,000 | Louise Bogan |
| Rolfe Humphries | ||||
| Randall Jarrell | ||||
| May Sarton | ||||
| Mark Van Doren |