| Year | Title | Publisher | Prize Amount | Judges |
| 1964 | Heroes, Advise Us | Scribner | $5,000 | Thomas Hornsby Ferril |
| William Meredith | ||||
| Louis Simpson | ||||
| William Jay Smith | ||||
| May Swenson |
| Year | Title | Publisher | Prize Amount | Judges |
| 1964 | Heroes, Advise Us | Scribner | $5,000 | Thomas Hornsby Ferril |
| William Meredith | ||||
| Louis Simpson | ||||
| William Jay Smith | ||||
| May Swenson |