When Bad Things Happen to Good People

You can only hear you look like a hooker so many times
before you become one. Spandex was really big 

the year I stopped believing.
I babysat for the rabbi’s son, Isaac. There was luxe carpet

in every room of the condo. Isaac liked Legos
and we made a pasture and a patriarch and lots of wives.

In his car in his garage the rabbi handed me a self-help book
and put my hand on his crotch, ready to go.

I didn’t care. 
I made good money. 

Isaac lived to be 180 according to the bible. 
Isaac is the only patriarch who didn’t have concubines. 

Isaac is 30 now. Modern scholarship tells us 

the patriarchs never existed. Experience taught me 
the patriarchs are all we’ve got.

Credit

Copyright © 2019 by Lynn Melnick. Originally published in Poem-a-Day on July 8, 2019, by the Academy of American Poets.

About this Poem

“The poem takes its title from the best-selling 1981 self-help book by Harold Kushner. I wrote this poem during my fellowship year at the Cullman Center for Scholars and Writers at the New York Public Library. I had come to the center with the plan to write into my Jewish heritage and my feelings about it, which is some of what I'm doing in this poem, but I also found myself thinking a lot about patriarchy and rape culture—the things I am always thinking about—and thinking in particular about the ways in which I've sold my body to men. The speaker here is a much younger me trying to figure out how to survive inside a rape culture of which she’s just becoming aware and which is seemingly everywhere and endless—and we’re both feeling pretty defeated by it.”
—Lynn Melnick